Some red and amber-listed species may still be shot but as Julian Thomas rightly says there is no evidence it drives declines: Our letter to BirdWatch

Some red and amber-listed species may still be shot (Birdwatch Magazine, issue 338:42-45), but as Julian Thomas rightly says there is no evidence it drives declines. In contrast there is strong evidence, from across Europe, that shooting can provide the crucial long-term motive to improve habitats and protect ground nesting species from predation. Clearly, those interested in shooting have a vested interest in their quarry and destroying this link would throw the baby out with the bath water. Unfortunately this has already happened in Germany which has incredibly low densities of Grey Partridges. As a result, the bird is now classified as critically endangered in three states, endangered in eight and vulnerable in three with shooting greatly restricted or banned by law or voluntarily across half the country.

In contrast we may  shoot them here and on the 900 farms in the GWCT Partridge Count Scheme we found an 81% increase in partridge pairs on count farms between 2000 and 2010, whereas national figures for the same period was a decline of 40%. That is why the GWCT is willing to work with and encourage landowners prepared to make that commitment for a wide range of species. Restoring wildlife on modern farmland requires serious conservation measures and somebody has to make that commitment and supply the funds in the long term. This is a complex link, but one all agreed as part of the Bern Convention on Biodiversity, so we must apply the precautionary principle and avoid dismantling an activity which is driving the local recovery of threatened species.

 Andrew Gilruth

Director of Communications

Please donate to help us continue our vital work during this difficult time


Make a comment

Cookie Policy

Our website uses cookies to provide you with a better online experience. If you continue to use our site without changing your browser settings, we'll assume you are happy to receive cookies. Please read our cookie policy for more information.

Do not show this message again