Our current moorland management system isn’t broken: Our letter to the Scotsman

The article Game estates must stop preying on our precious raptors and follow the law (The Scotsman, 16 January 2019, page 30/31) is yet another attempt to exert influence over the Independent Review on Grouse Moor Management by highlighting what we all agree is outdated and abhorrent practice, but does not by any means mean that the current, and evolving, management system that we have is broken.  Far from it as figures show that last year illegal poisonings of birds of prey fell to a record low.

Arguably, self-regulation has not failed but is becoming increasingly effective and the direction of travel is positive.

The Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust wants to see an end to the conflict surrounding red grouse and raptors and the adoption of a system that can work well for all interests within existing legislation. That does not mean that grouse shooting and its thoroughly researched and documented conservation, economic and cultural benefits should be consigned to history, or stifled by additional legislation.

What is required is a more holistic and adaptive approach to species management, delivering multiple conservation benefits, where traditional moorland management can be married to new systems and techniques. This would support both healthy heather moorland and higher raptor numbers across the country as a whole.  That, we think is within our grasp.

David Noble
GWCT Scotland chairman

Help us tell The Untold Story about conservation


The public aren’t being told about the vital work being done in the British countryside by land managers. You don’t hear much about the good work they're doing. Their contribution is criminally overlooked. You can change that today.

  • £25 will pay for 10 copies of our vital new publication The Untold Story to be sent to journalists & policymakers
  • £70 will help us to get journalists out to see the real work that is being done in our countryside
  • £125 supports us in briefing the public through advertising, press and online activity 

Donate by Credit or Debit Card >>

Got a PayPal account? Donate faster here:
Paypalcheckout .fw


Make a comment

Cookie Policy

Our website uses cookies to provide you with a better online experience. If you continue to use our site without changing your browser settings, we'll assume you are happy to receive cookies. Please read our cookie policy for more information.

Do not show this message again