The Agreement on International Humane Trapping Standards (AIHTS) is an attempt to establish and enforce an international standard on humaneness for traps. It’s being implemented in the UK on 1 April 2020, so here is what you need to know.
[Updated 27 February 2020]
What is AIHTS?
The Agreement on International Humane Trapping Standards (AIHTS) was brokered in 1997 to resolve a trade embargo threatened by the EU in 1991 against countries that traded fur from wild animals caught by inhumane methods. The dispute had begun with pressure inside the EU from animal rights groups protesting against fur trade, focused particularly on the use of leg-hold traps. This backfired to some extent because fur-trading nations pointed out that similar traps were commonly used in EU countries to catch the same species (e.g. muskrat, coypu) or similar species as pests, and that no humaneness standards were applied there. Because fur trading was economically important — particularly for Canada and Russia, but also for some EU countries like Denmark and Iceland — and because pest control was also critical, a compromise was thrashed out: the AIHTS. This requires signatory countries to prohibit traps for fur-bearing species that will not pass a clearly specified humaneness test.
The AIHTS humaneness test was derived from discussions towards an international standard on humaneness in traps, a process which had been derailed by animal rights lobbyists within the technical working group, who ultimately asserted that no trap could ever be considered humane. The ISO standard salvaged from those failed discussions defined how to test traps but stopped short of defining a threshold for acceptability. An acceptability standard was defined in AIHTS. This reflects performance of the better traps available, but is nevertheless realistic.
AIHTS applies only to a list of species commonly caught in the wild for their fur. Of these, only otter, beaver, marten, badger and stoat occur in the UK, and under current UK law only stoat may be taken or killed without special licence. This will change with the introduction of a new General Licence to control stoats from 1 April 2020. Notably missing from the AIHTS list are mink and fox. This is because fur from those species is mostly taken from fur farm stock, to ensure consistency, and to use variants that are rare in the wild. Weasel is also not listed: this is because it is not caught as a furbearer.
The AIHTS standard is not fixed, and it was anticipated that both the humaneness criteria and the list of species to which AIHTS applied would evolve in time.
A timeline for the evolution of AIHTS and its implementation by signatory countries can be found here.
What does AIHTS mean for gamekeepers?
The 2018/19 Spring Traps Approval and Amendment Orders of Scotland, England and Wales and Northern Ireland detail changes to the list of traps that are approved to catch stoats. From what we already know about trap performance, the Fenn Mk 4 and Mk 6 traps (and copycat designs), and all the BMI Magnum traps fail the AIHTS standard. These probably account for 90% or more of all traps currently used as tunnel traps in the UK.
So the main likely consequences of AIHTS are:
- Cost of replacement traps
- Modification of tunnels to suit replacement traps
- Cost of deployment in the field
- It will probably be necessary for rat and squirrel control to become separate exercises using pre-baiting, appropriate baits, in more intensive campaigns focused on specific locations. Stoats can then be targeted using traps approved for them, with suitably restricted entrances to the tunnels. Weasels are approved for capture in the new generation of approved stoat traps and trappers are urged to embrace change to include weasel control.
Some other traps currently approved for stoat have not been tested to AIHTS standard and are unlikely to be tested because of lack of interest from the manufacturer or the user community. These include the WCS tube trap, which thus ceases to be legal for stoats on 1 April 2020.
Are Fenn traps going to be made illegal?
Fenn traps, and all copycat designs such as those by Springer and Solway, will be made illegal to catch stoats from 1 April 2020, because tests have shown that they fail to kill stoats reliably within the time-frame required by AIHTS (45 seconds). It will remain legal to use them to catch other target species for which they are currently approved (e.g. weasels, rats, grey squirrels), even though they have not undergone humaneness testing for those species (because of cost constraints). But the AIHTS does not apply to those other species, and Defra is implementing AIHTS by means of the least possible change. Note that the traps must be set in a tunnel ‘suitable for the purpose’, which means species like stoat, for which the trap is not approved, must not be put at risk. We think this will be difficult to achieve in many circumstances where the use of these traps would otherwise be lawful; we therefore encourage trappers to assess the risk and embrace change.
Is the UK obliged to implement AIHTS?
The AIHTS is binding on all EU member states, and Defra has indicated that the UK remains committed to it after Brexit. Morally, a commitment to raise humaneness standards in wildlife management is unarguable, provided it doesn’t render management ineffectual or prohibitively expensive.
Why didn’t we get more warning?
The AIHTS allowed an eight-year period for implementation, from the moment the agreement was signed in 2008. Most of this was squandered through protracted negotiations and indecision within the EU and lack of preparedness at member-state level. As far as we know, only Sweden, Finland, Slovakia and possibly Hungary were already compliant with AIHTS by the July 2016 deadline. See the next section for more detail about the UK specifically.
Because few fur-bearing species addressed by AIHTS are trapped in the UK, the UK was largely compliant by July 2016, with stoats the principle outstanding issue. The problem with stoats was that no trap had been found that made a satisfactory substitute for Fenn traps from a practitioner’s point of view. The UK therefore argued that it needed extra time to facilitate changes.
How did the UK reach the current predicament?
Following completion of signatures to the AIHTS in 2008, a period of five years was allowed for trap testing to take place, followed by three years for trap users to make any necessary changes to their practices. The total eight-year transition expired at the end of July 2016. The GWCT began warning about the implications of AIHTS for predator and pest management in 1997, with an article in the Review, but the UK was slow to implement AIHTS. In part, this was because, for four years after ratification, the EU was apparently working towards a Directive on the matter. The EU dropped that ambition in 2012, arguing that member countries should in any case be implementing the agreement in their domestic law. That still left four years before implementation had to be complete.
In the UK, Defra is the government department responsible for regulation of spring traps (Pests Act 1954). All spring traps must be approved by Defra, although there has not previously been any published standard they must conform to for approval. In 2012, Defra stated that future new trap approvals would be granted only to traps that pass the AIHTS standard, irrespective of species. They even extended this scrutiny to fox snares, which did not fall under either the Pests Act (because a snare is not a spring trap) or AIHTS (because fox is not one of the species it covers).
Defra finally got to grips with implementation of AIHTS in spring 2015, leaving only 15 months of the original eight years to complete trap testing, amend legislation relating to traps, inform the trap-using community of changes to trap approvals, and for the ‘industry’ (manufacturers, importers, retailers, users) to effect those changes. In spring 2015, Defra held discussions with organisations (including the GWCT) associated with shooting and pest control, and with UK trap manufacturers/retailers, to clarify the options for trap testing and trap approvals. Defra expected to progress to a public consultation on the matter by the end of September 2015, but this was deferred pending further developments. When the deadline of July 2016 passed, no suitable substitutes for failed stoat traps had been identified.
Subsequently, however, Defra set up a Technical Working Group with members from organisations representing all the major practitioner groups (including the GWCT). This group oversees the use of a fund to cover the cost of humaneness-testing for promising candidate traps. 50% of the fund was put up by Defra; 50% by the other members of the group. It is expected to be sufficient to see a handful of models through to approval. Trap-testing progress has been slow, chiefly because of a shortage of suitable candidate traps that are developed to a point where they could be manufactured in quantity.
Defra has proposed that in future, those who submit new traps for approval (i.e. manufacturers/importers/retailers) will have to bear the (substantial) cost of trap testing.
What is the UK situation as of February 2020?
In July 2018, Defra announced its response to the public consultation on implementation of the AIHTS in the UK. This confirmed how implementation would be carried out and set a deadline for withdrawal of stoat traps that failed the required humaneness tests.
Implementation would involve changes to the schedules of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, including making stoat a species that may not be trapped except under the terms of a licence; deletions and additions to the lists of approved traps (Spring Traps Approval Orders or STAOs), which are issued separately in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland; and the issue of new General Licences, allowing the capture of stoats using traps approved in the STAOs.
These changes have now been achieved through the Humane Trapping Standards Regulation 2019, and the publications of the Spring Traps Approval (England) Order 2018, Spring Traps Approval (Wales) Order 2019, and Spring Traps (Scotland) Amendment Order 2018. Some new trap approvals have been made, adding some humane alternatives for stoat control and broadening the options for humane grey squirrel control. The following table shows all trap approvals that will be valid from 1 April 2020, and the humaneness testing on which they are based. In some cases, the conditions of use stated in the STAO and repeated in this table refer to manufacturers’ instructions, which must be followed. UK instructions for the DOC traps are available at the manufacturer’s website here.
Thus, from 1 April 2020, it will no longer be lawful to use Fenn-type traps (Fenn, Springer, Solway and copies of these traps); Magnum 55, 110, 116; or WCS Tube Traps to catch stoats. From this date, stoats may only be caught in spring traps or live traps listed in new General Licences issued separately in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland (similar to those in place allowing the trapping of corvid birds). It is hoped these licences will become available during March 2020, but the spring traps listed will presumably be those approved in the STAOs, so there should be no surprises there.
Trap approvals valid from 1 April 2020
(click to download spreadsheet)
How did the GWCT respond to Defra’s consultation on AIHTS?
Our full response can be found here.
These changes have now been achieved through the Humane Trapping Standards Regulation 2019, and the publications of the Spring Traps Approval (England) Order 2018, Spring Traps Approval (Wales) Order 2019, and Spring Traps (Scotland) Variation Order 2018. Some new trap approvals have been made, adding some humane alternatives for stoat control, and broadening the options for humane grey squirrel control. The following table shows all trap approvals that will be valid into the future, and the humaneness testing on which they are based. In some cases, the conditions of use stated in the STAO and repeated in this table refer to manufacturers’ instructions, which must be followed. UK instructions for the DOC traps are available at the manufacturer’s website here.
A 12-month grace period is allowed between implementation being completed and the phasing-out of non-compliant stoat traps. Thus from 1 April 2020, it will no longer be lawful to use Fenn-type traps (Fenn, Springer, Solway and copies of these traps), Magnum 55, 110, 116 or WCS Tube Traps to catch stoats. From this date, stoats may only be caught in spring traps or live traps listed in General Licences issued separately in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland (similar to those in place allowing the trapping of corvid birds). These licences are not yet available, but the spring traps listed will presumably be those approved in the STAOs, so there should be no surprises there unless further approvals are added before 1 April 2020.